Skip to content

feat: allow profile routing overrides and revise presets - #26

Merged
transparent-pegasus merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
fix/generalist-orchestrator
Nov 10, 2026
Merged

transparent-pegasus merged 2 commits into
mainfrom
fix/generalist-orchestrator

Conversation

@transparent-pegasus

@transparent-pegasus transparent-pegasus commented Nov 10, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Who is submitting this PR? (required)

Field Value
Your model + version GPT-6 family; exact runtime model ID is not exposed
Harness + version Codex API workspace; host version is not exposed
All plugins installed Session catalog: herdrpowers 1.21.0, artful-simplicity 0.1.0, plugin-management 0.1.0, sites 1.1.6, work-pets 0.1.6; full installed inventory is not exposed
Human partner who reviewed this diff Pending; implementation and final self-review ran inline in the author session

What problem are you trying to solve?

Profiles could select models but could not delegate planning or override routing settings. The smaller presets spent the upper model on execution instead of reserving it for planning and reviews.

What does this PR change?

Profiles now override present fallbacks, delegation, and assignments keys, including individual task fields; omitted keys retain config/default values and lists replace, including []. Ship sol-astra and opus-fable with an explicit cheaper owner, upper-model planning/review, and plan-and-design.mode: delegate; rename both -panel presets to -ultra. Synchronize the contract and its readers, and pass frozen effective pane scope to the lifecycle helper while keeping lifecycle permission config-only.

Is this change appropriate for the core pack?

Yes. This extends the existing profile contract and shipped presets across supported consumers; it adds no service or dependency.

What alternatives did you consider?

Editing repository config for each preset would couple reusable profiles to local state. Adding a YAML runtime would duplicate the agent-interpreted contract; the existing helper instead accepts the frozen resolved scope.

Does this PR contain multiple unrelated changes?

No. Contract, presets, routing readers, lifecycle scope, packaging tests, and changelog implement the same profile behavior.

Existing PRs

Reviewed all open and closed PR titles for duplicates; no open PR covers this change. Related: #23, #24, #25. This continues #25, which was already merged, on the same fix/generalist-orchestrator branch.

Environment tested

Harness Harness version Model Model version/ID
Codex API workspace Not exposed GPT-6 family Exact runtime ID not exposed

Tests execute the real shell helpers against the repository's offline Herdr stubs. No live pane, model-footer, or agent behavior sampling is claimed.

New harness support

Not applicable; no new harness support.

Evaluation

Initial request: continue #25 inline; add present-only profile routing overrides; revise presets; test, commit, push, and create a PR without merging. Final requested names, explicit Sol/Opus owners, and orchestrator-first key order are reflected below. Without an orchestrator entry, planning-design stays first; generalist stays last.

Live eval sessions: 0. Regression tests failed before implementation on old asset names, ignored resolved scope, and the old preset key order, then passed after the changes. Final results:

  • node --test tests/pane-model/pane.test.mjs tests/composer-submit/submit.test.mjs tests/orchestration-profiles/profiles.test.mjs tests/agent-lifecycle/lifecycle.test.mjs tests/opencode/plugin.test.mjs: 125/125 passed, no skips.
  • bash tests/pane-model/run.sh: 26 passed.
  • bash tests/pane-model/effort.sh: 45 passed.
  • bash tests/pane-model/muse.sh: 22 passed.
  • bash tests/skill-size/test-skill-size.sh: passed.
  • Both claude plugin validate .claude-plugin/plugin.json and claude plugin validate .: passed; warnings concern root CLAUDE.md context and the missing plugin icon.
  • OpenCode entry-point smoke: skills path and all seven commands registered.
  • Legacy/stale-reference scans and git diff --cached --check: clean.
  • Both ultra presets retain their targets. All six presets put orchestrator first, then planning-design, with generalist last; reordering preserves every top-level block value. Package contents contain exactly the six current presets and their README under .herdrpowers/.

Rigor

  • Live skill pressure testing completed; no live eval sessions were run.
  • Offline adversarial cases cover narrower/wider scope, invalid/empty scope, and lifecycle denial without sent keys or ledger writes.
  • Red Flags tables, rationalization tables, and human-partner language were not changed.

Human review

  • A human has reviewed the complete proposed diff before submission.

Draft PR: human review is pending. The requester explicitly authorized uninterrupted execution through PR creation. Final review was author self-review; no independent review is claimed. Do not merge.

Changed files

M	.herdrpowers/profiles/README.md
D	.herdrpowers/profiles/astra-sol.yaml
R100	.herdrpowers/profiles/fable-opus-panel.yaml	.herdrpowers/profiles/fable-opus-ultra.yaml
D	.herdrpowers/profiles/fable-opus.yaml
R100	.herdrpowers/profiles/fable-sol-panel.yaml	.herdrpowers/profiles/fable-sol-ultra.yaml
A	.herdrpowers/profiles/opus-fable.yaml
M	.herdrpowers/profiles/opus-solo.yaml
A	.herdrpowers/profiles/sol-astra.yaml
M	.herdrpowers/profiles/sol-solo.yaml
M	CLAUDE.md
M	README.md
A	changelogs/2026-11-11-profile-overrides-and-presets.md
M	commands/execute.md
M	commands/execute_parallel.md
M	commands/full_cycle.md
M	commands/init.md
M	commands/plan.md
M	commands/quick.md
M	docs/development_cycle.md
M	docs/instruction_snippet.md
M	docs/roles.md
M	docs/skills.md
M	docs/workflows.md
M	skills/orchestration/README.md
M	skills/orchestration/SKILL.md
M	skills/orchestration/references/profiles.md
M	skills/orchestration/references/routing.md
M	skills/orchestration/roles.yaml
M	skills/pane-driven-development/references/assignments.md
M	skills/requesting-code-review/SKILL.md
M	skills/test-driven-development/SKILL.md
M	skills/using-herdr-sibling-panes/SKILL.md
M	skills/using-herdr-sibling-panes/references/agent-lifecycle.md
M	skills/using-herdr-sibling-panes/scripts/agent-lifecycle.sh
M	skills/writing-plans/SKILL.md
M	tests/agent-lifecycle/lifecycle.test.mjs
M	tests/orchestration-profiles/profiles.test.mjs

Presets in full

sol-astra.yaml

orchestrator:
  codex:
    model: GPT-6.1-Sol
    effort: max
planning-design:
  codex:
    model: GPT-6-Astra
    effort: max
coder: orchestrator
reviewers:
  - codex:
      model: GPT-6-Astra
      effort: max
assignments:
  plan-and-design:
    mode: delegate
generalist: orchestrator

opus-fable.yaml

orchestrator:
  claude:
    model: Opus 5.5
    effort: max
planning-design:
  claude:
    model: Fable 5.2
    effort: max
coder: orchestrator
reviewers:
  - claude:
      model: Fable 5.2
      effort: max
assignments:
  plan-and-design:
    mode: delegate
generalist: orchestrator

fable-sol-ultra.yaml

orchestrator:
  claude:
    model: Fable 5.2
    effort: max
planning-design: orchestrator
coder:
  codex:
    model: GPT-6.1-Sol
    effort: max
reviewers:
  - codex:
      model: GPT-6-Astra
      effort: max
  - muse:
      model: muse-1.0-wonder
      effort: max
  - agy:
      model: Gemini 4 Argon
      effort: High
  - cursor:
      model: Grok 4.7
      effort: Extra High
generalist: orchestrator

fable-opus-ultra.yaml

orchestrator:
  claude:
    model: Fable 5.2
    effort: max
planning-design: orchestrator
coder:
  claude:
    model: Opus 5.5
    effort: max
reviewers:
  - codex:
      model: GPT-6-Astra
      effort: max
  - muse:
      model: muse-1.0-wonder
      effort: max
  - agy:
      model: Gemini 4 Argon
      effort: High
  - cursor:
      model: Grok 4.7
      effort: Extra High
generalist: orchestrator

sol-solo.yaml

orchestrator:
  codex:
    model: GPT-6.1-Sol
    effort: max
planning-design: orchestrator
coder: orchestrator
reviewers: [orchestrator]
generalist: orchestrator

opus-solo.yaml

orchestrator:
  claude:
    model: Opus 5.5
    effort: max
planning-design: orchestrator
coder: orchestrator
reviewers: [orchestrator]
generalist: orchestrator

@transparent-pegasus
transparent-pegasus marked this pull request as ready for review November 10, 2026 21:38
@transparent-pegasus
transparent-pegasus merged commit 9ce214d into main Nov 10, 2026
2 checks passed
@transparent-pegasus
transparent-pegasus deleted the fix/generalist-orchestrator branch November 11, 2026 19:10
transparent-pegasus added a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 17, 2026
…trator

feat: allow profile routing overrides and revise presets
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant